I was halfway through an interview about this year’s Honda Indy Toronto with Jim Ralph and Bill Watters on AM 640 when the inevitable question was asked: how was the race day attendance?
And I answered as honestly as I could – since the event has chosen once again to not release a figure.
I said on the radio that I thought it was about the size of a "BMO Field" crowd – 20,000 to 25,000, maybe a tad more. I based this on a seat and head count.
I went to the Honda Indy website in the days leading up to the race and I clicked on "tickets." That eventually took me to the seating pattern for the grandstands. For instance, Section A in one grandstand had 18 seats across and was 20 rows high; I clicked on all the sections of all the grandstands and did the math. I tabulated the totals and got a figure of just under 16,000 seats – most of which were filled on race day.
Then I added an estimated 2,000 to 2,500 suite seats, 1,000 general admission seats along Lake Shore Blvd., 1,000 or so drivers, team members, volunteers, paid workers, security, etc., and then a whole bunch of people just wandering around and came up with the 20,000-to-25,000 figure.
Now, that was not for the weekend – Free Friday attracted a ton of people and since there was no admission and nothing was reserved, there was no way to estimate a total. And Saturday and Sunday had lots of people on and about the grounds and inside the Direct Energy Centre. So maybe my estimate was low – although not by much. I mean, I’ve been around.
But in the end, so what?
Right now, today, the Toronto Blue Jays are attracting an average crowd of just over 21,000 fans per game. Mostly, they get between 11,000 and 16,000 a game and the average gets bumped up by things like opening day, Roy Halladay, the Yankees and the Red Sox. The rest of the time, you can shoot a cannon through the place and not hit anybody.
But does anybody in the media go on about attendance at Blue Jays games?
Nope.
I’ve cited this stupidity before and I’ll do it again. The Toronto media routinely report that a million people show up for the Gay Pride parade every year. It is mathematically impossible for this to happen but it gets reported anyway. In fact, CFTO, on Gay Pride parade night, bumped that figure up to an attendance of "1.5 to 2 million (which would have meant just about every man, woman, child and infant in the entire city showed up)."
Total nonsense, but reported anyway.
Same with the Scotiabank Caribbean Festival (nee Caribana), the Taste of the Danforth and so-on. They all allegedly attract a million people.
If the promoters of the Honda Indy made an initial mistake, it’s this: they should have announced that a million people attended the first race in 2009. That way, the race attendance would have fit in nicely with all the other exaggerated attendance figures around here and, as is the case with the other events, nobody would have questioned it.
In the end, however, does it really matter how many people were actually there?
The TV figures were over the top. TSN announced that an average audience of 559,000 watched the race and that, overall, more than 1.2 million tuned in. The peak came as Dario Franchitti held off Scott Dixon to win; at 4:46 p.m., 735,000 were watching.
TSN said it was the best-watched Indy car race on the network since 1997, when CART was the sanctioning body and the race was known as the Molson Indy (and yes, those days are gone, never to return, just like the every-day sellout that was the norm at SkyDome before the baseball players' strike in 1994).
In the U.S., the little-known cable network Versus drew a .41 rating, which translates into a shade more than 400,000. So between one million and 1.6 million in North America watched the race, or some of it. (It would have been more if the race had been on a major U.S. network, which is something that IndyCar simply cannot ignore much longer.)
Corporate support for the event, meantime, is solid. The U.S. retailer Target, which sponsors Chip Ganassi’s racing team with Franchitti and Dixon driving, flew in all its top U.S. executives and introduced its Canadian management team to the media before the race on Sunday and emphasized its commitment to the IZOD IndyCar Series and the Toronto Indy.
They had "Target ambassadors" handing out free stuff on the grounds and they’re not even opening for business in Canada till 2013!
And several hundred media members – newspaper, magazine and website reporters and photographers from all over North America and several from Europe and Asia – sent stories and pictures about the race back to their publications and Internet sites.
So when you look at the big picture, you have solid TV numbers (which is what advertisers are really looking for), solid media interest and serious corporate support and commitment. What more can an event like this ask for?
Toronto, and the Indy car race through its streets last Sunday, looked pretty darn good in the eyes of the world.
Which is cause for celebration, not criticism.
Good to hear a positive news story regarding the Honda Indy for a change, well done Norris.
Many are eager to knock this event and IndyCar in general, having also attended this years event as a member of the media I too found that the weekend had a good turnout and general vibe.
Congratulations to the event organisers and all that came out during the weekend!
Posted by: James Foreman | 07/13/2011 at 10:15 AM
The numbers thing gets me too. Why do they even bother? I guess someone wants to show certain events are extremely popular. Funnily, when they estimate the crowd at the annual "Jesus in the City" parade they hardly go past a few thousands . Ah, the media...
Posted by: Colin W | 07/13/2011 at 11:27 AM
Who in the hell cares? It is about the racing not attendance numbers
Posted by: John JR Revelle | 07/13/2011 at 12:23 PM
A lot more paying spectators could be had if the sightlines and positions of the bleachers is improved. Right now, the Gold grandstand, for example, has horrendeous visibility. Meaningless, unexciting.
Most of the best corners are off limits to spectators.
Some corners are hugged by beer gardens where those spending time are not that much interested in the race as in the beer and the girls. The Budweiser beer garden is not a welcoming place also because the security guard in front randomly searches the bags for something presumably totally unrelated to auto racing.
I would not pay for admission to see this race. The TV coverage is better.
Posted by: Adam | 07/13/2011 at 12:43 PM
Good to read a story about sensible attendance figures. The million, million plus that attended the gay pride parade is such a joke. If you want to see a million people google pictures from the Hajih to Mecca every year. Now there is a million people.
Posted by: Nick | 07/13/2011 at 01:20 PM
Norris, I hope you realise that the Million plus attendance figures for Pride and Caribana are for the festivals, not just the parade. Pride is 10 days long, and Caribana is about a week, if I recall correctly.
Posted by: Thane | 07/14/2011 at 01:14 AM
You do realize that people come from outside Toronto to go to the gay pride festival and caribana right?
Posted by: Justin | 07/14/2011 at 10:44 AM
The more salient point Mr. McDonald made is this is not the MOLSON INDY of years past....and that's why attendance is important as a gauge of the health of this event.
Let's face facts...today's Indycar is not CART or CCWS of yesteryear. Canadian's and traveling American fans know this with certainty. And that's why 169,000 fans of yesteryear refuse to go to this farce of an event featuring the IRL/Indycars.
If it wasn't for the buffoonery of constant crashes, drivers calling each other 'wanker', and the shear idiocy of the stewards in race control at this event would have gone un-noticed far and wide.
So, let's take it for what it is Norris, something far less than what it once was. And so is attendance, sponsorships and TV ratings. That is the truth, indeed.
Posted by: Chief | 07/14/2011 at 11:30 AM
The numbers for events such as Pride, Taste of the Danforth etc. are based differently than an enclosed event. People are coming and going throughout the weekend. With a ball game or a race, people are generally going there and staying.
Anyway, loved the race, it was really exciting and I love the double row of cars on re-starts.
Posted by: Molly | 07/14/2011 at 10:17 PM
Why is attendance important? Because without attendance we don't have the race. And do you not realize Norm that people come from all over the world to attend the different festivals in this city and that the numbers, for a lot of it, come from the pretty impressive plane ticket sales. Neither Caribana nor Pride are local festivals but world festivals. And that is where the numbers come from.
Posted by: rdk | 07/15/2011 at 12:26 AM
Great comments re attendance! My favourite is the "million" that attend the Beaches Jazz Fest each year!
Posted by: Paul E | 07/15/2011 at 10:18 AM
The worst race I have ever seen on television. Poor camera work, abysmal commentating (including "fabricated penalties"), brutal track conditions etc;
Hey Mr. Eccelstone... put us out of our IndyCar nightmare and get a real race here. For the love of Pete!
Posted by: Rob Taylor | 07/15/2011 at 02:53 PM
Are you kidding Paul. Do you honestly believe that F1 would come and race here in Toronto. Any of the new events going on the F1 calendar have spent hundreds of millions of dollars on a track and facilities. The only track in F1 that uses actual roads currently on the calendar is Monaco and all involved pretty much agree Monaco would never get approval as a new race in these times it is only because the race is loved so and money that Monaco is allowed to continue. Lets face it the Toronto street course is a joke.
Posted by: Markymark2112 | 07/18/2011 at 08:19 AM
Slowly the Canadian fans of Indy Car are returning to the combined series "Indy Car". There are a few who will never get over there hatred of the IRL, but most Canadian fans understand that we are back to one Indy Car series and the racing is pretty exciting.
Glad to see the event growing each year.
Posted by: Brad Dill | 07/19/2011 at 12:35 PM