The recently re-hired Blue Jays' manager, John Gibbons, sometimes misunderstood but never misleading, had just returned to his family home in south Texas after fulfilling key off-season obligations to his new/old employer. It was a bright and sunny mid-January mid-morning in San Antonio, following the bone-chilling experience of a winter weekend
in Edmonton on the Jays' winter tour.
The Star had flown in from Toronto the night before to meet with the 50-year-old former MLB catcher, the unexpectedly-reprised Jays' skipper, to find out what may have changed for him in the past four-plus years since he was fired mid-season in 2008, what had remained the same, since that mixed-bag experience as manager the first time around.
Following a walking tour of the downtown, remembering the Alamo and the Riverwalk, we stopped in for lunch at a place called The Esquire Tavern, billing itself as the oldest drinking establishment in San Antonio, with the longest solid wood bar in town. It was dark, quiet, the beer was cold. They had me at "Hello."
San Antonio is also home to former Jays' skipper Cito Gaston, former Jays' DH Cliff Johnson, late Jays' super-scout Al LaMacchia, U.S. General Douglas MacArthur, former Mets catcher Jerry Grote, actor Tommy Lee Jones, four active U.S. military bases and the NBA powerhouse Spurs. It seems a perfect match for Gibbons, low-key, friendly and seemingly underappreciated.
Following is the totality of that Gibbons unplugged interview, offering a relaxed, reflective, realistic look at his life and career.The headings here are merely for purposes of navigation, although the full read is well worth it.
1-GIBBONS FAMILY SAN ANTONIO CONNECTION
2-SURPRISE FIRST-ROUND DRAFT PICK BY
THE METS
3-DISAPPOINTING PLAYING CAREER LEADS TO CAREER IN COACHING
4- “NOT MY JOHN GIBBONS”: DAVEY JOHNSON
5-FAMOUS CONFLICTS WITH JAYS
PLAYERS
6-FIRED FOR THE FIRST TIME; STAYS
BUSY BETWEEN JAYS STINTS
7-QUE SERA SERA CAREER -- BLOND
AMBITION
8-DEVELOPING KEY RELATIONSHIPS FOR THE FUTURE WITH METS
9-GIBBY'S DEVELOPING RELATIONSHIP WITH
ALEX
10-HANDLING A DIVERSE BLUE JAYS
CLUBHOUSE
11-COULD HAVE BEEN A LONGHORN WITH
CLEMENS
* * * * * * * * *
1-GIBBONS FAMILY SAN ANTONIO CONNECTION
RICHARD GRIFFIN: You're from a military
family. Is that the reason your birthplace is in Great Falls (MT)? There's a
major NORAD military base there. I flew in when Tim Johnson was named Jays' manager in '97. And there are military bases in
San Antonio too. Is that why your dad (Bill Gibbons, a Boston native) moved here?
JOHN GIBBONS: My sister and I were born
in Great Falls. My father was stationed out there for two years,
1962. We bounced around when we were really young. Then he got
stationed here in San Antonio when I was in the fourth grade. I've
been here ever since. He had an assignment that was 13 years, which
is unheard of in the military. I ended up spending my whole school
years here. He finished it up in Bolling Air Force Base in D.C., then
retired. San Antonio is one of the bigger military towns.
RG: What was his top rank?
JG: He retired a full-bird colonel.
Thirty years.
RG: You said your mom's still here. Did your
parents move back here after he retired, or did they always make San
Antonio home?
JG: When they finished up in D.C. he
came back here and retired here. You get everything you need with the
(military) bases here.
RG: And by then you had already been
drafted (by the Mets) and moved ahead with your career.
JG: Yeah, by then I was out playing
ball and would come back in the winter.
RG: Did you ever think of moving the
family anywhere else or is it that you just loved this area?
JG: This is home. I've been here for so
long. My wife (Julie MacFarlane) grew up in El Paso, Texas. She went
to high school right outside here, so it's kind of a natural fit for
us. It's a good town. We've enjoyed it.
RG: What about your kids?
JG: My daughter's my oldest one. She's
20. There's Jordan. Middle son, Troy, 18. And then Kyle, my little
one, 13.
RG: The relationship with your dad,
when he was sick, it seemed that – and I know father-son
relationships are close – but it seemed to affect you tremendously
at the time.
JG: In 2006 he found out that he was
sick. Everybody goes through it. It's part of life. You get older,
everybody's touched by it. Just being away. You know, the end's
coming and you're not there. That adds...that takes it's toll on you.
You don't know if you're going to see him again. I was able that one
year to sneak home for a couple of days (during the season). The team
went to Kansas City and (GM J.P.) Ricciardi told me, 'Go ahead, take
a couple of days,' so I met the team back in Kansas City. He hung on
'til I got home then he died in January, 2007.
RG: Your mom has come to grips with it
and she's doing fine now?
JG: Yeah, she's fine. She's a very
independent woman. Life goes on. It gets us all sooner or later. One
thing is nobody gets out alive. She's always been into horses her
whole life and so that's kind of her thing. She's still riding,
actually, at 74.
2-SURPRISE FIRST-ROUND DRAFT PICK BY THE METS
RG: That 1980 draft the Mets had three
choices in the first and four among the first 35...
JG: The Mets hit it (in the draft) the year following
(laughs). They had some pretty good drafts. (Darryl) Strawberry
(first overall) turned out to be a pretty good player. He may have
had other issues. Billy Beane (No. 23 overall), he struggled like I
did and turned it into something else (as GM of the A's).
RG: That first minor-league spring
training (in '81) with the Mets...was J.P. at that training camp, or
was he signed after that?
JG: No, J.P. would have been there
because I played with him in '81 in Shelby, North Carolina.
RG: So it would have been you and Billy
and Straw and all those young guys in that signing class. What was
your thought about your future being a hotshot draft pick and all
that, at that point?
JG: You're on top of the world. You
think you're guaranteed to be a major-leaguer, but that's not the
reality. I've always been a humble individual I think, for the most
part. I never really got carried away with myself. But you could see
it.
Coming out of high school, I was pretty
good. I got drafted high. But you look at a guy like Strawberry, I
mean there's something different about it. Everything's easy. Myself,
I had to work for things. Even Beane. He was a very talented kid, but
mentally it just got away from him. You think the sky's the limit.
You don't think it's going to be easy, but here it is, a dream come
true, now do something with it.
I actually moved up through the system
on a good pace. Then in 1984, going into spring training (the Mets)
threw the catching job up for grabs. I came into camp, there was
myself, Ron Hodges, Mike Fitzgerald, Ronn Reynolds and Junior Ortiz.
Those were the five guys that were there.
I had had a good year in Double-A in
'83. Davey Johnson was the (Mets) new manager and he'd seen me play.
He liked what I did, apparently. I had a good spring training, they
gave me the job and then two days before we broke camp, I took an
elbow in the cheek on a play at the plate. Joe Lefebvre was with the
Phillies at the time. It was kind of a cheap shot. There was a throw
coming up the line. He was trying to score from third. The ball was
kind of drifting into him. He threw an elbow at me and cracked the
cheekbone. So I started the year on the DL, a couple of weeks, maybe.
But when I started playing again I wasn't
hitting anything. I think I was 0-for-15 (actually 0-for-12) and then
we played you guys (the Expos) at Shea Stadium (on April 17, 1984),
the Mets home opener. (Gary) Carter hit a grand slam (off Ron
Darling). It was Bryn Smith or Charlie Lea, whoever started (it was
Smith), I got my first hit. They say that after the first one they
come in bunches. Well, that wasn't the case (laughs). It was kind of
downhill from there. Then I injured my elbow, partially torn
ligament. That winter they traded for Carter, sending Hubie (Brooks)
and those guys. That was kind of it. Floyd (Youmans) had as good an
arm as any of them. He had as good an arm as Gooden did. The (Mets)
drafted some boneheads...talented though (laughs). Herm (Winningham)
had a nice career.
RG: What was your initial reaction when
they traded for Carter? Could you see writing on the wall?
JG: I thought, you know, I'm done here.
I can remember Steve Schreyver was the farm director at the time, he
called me after the trade and said, 'Listen, don't let this influence
you.' (laughs). I said OK. This guy's the best catcher in the game.
He's still a young man. I knew then that my chances of playing
here...there might be a shot at a backup job. So I went to the next
couple of spring trainings and there was really no shot at backing
up.
They wanted me playing every day. In '84 I was 21, so I was still a young
guy. They wanted me playing. Then the game started getting tougher on
me. Finally, Ed Hearn and Barry Lyons. (The Mets) went through a few
backups that did a pretty good job for them. Well I got called up a
couple of Septembers. That was it.
I was there in '86, I got called up in
August. Carter was playing first base and dove and dislocated his
thumb. I got called up from Triple-A and Ed Hearn and I were the
catchers. I was there two months and stayed with them through the
playoffs catching in the bullpen. I wasn't on the active roster.
The following year, I got called up
just in September, in '87. I couldn't sniff an inning. Not even a
blowout backup game. Throw me a bone, catch me an inning. I think we
were in St. Louis end of the season, I thought this is it. I've gotta
go somewhere else. I've gotta figure out whether I've got a career or
not. So I told the GM, Frank Cashen, that it's time.
They brought me to camp in '88 with the
Mets and eventually at the end of the spring they traded me for
(infielder) Craig Shipley, to the Dodgers. I went to Triple-A with
the Dodgers in Albuquerque and split time with Gil Reyes. That was
kind of it, then bounced around a couple of years in Triple-A.
Basically what I was doing was hanging on.
RG: So, what was the whole experience
like in the '86 World Series? Pretty exciting for a 24-year-old guy,
even though you weren't on the active roster, you were part of it.
JG: The first (playoff) series was in
Houston and my job was to warm up the pitchers. In Houston (at the
Astrodome) you're on the field warming up and that place was rocking.
It was such a great, classic series. You want to be part of the
action, but in a lot of ways it was intimidating at the time too. We ended up squeaking that out somehow. Then, of course, in the World
Series against the Red Sox I can remember in Game 6 just as all hell
broke loose (with Bill Buckner's error), Gooden was warming up right
after we started to get something going, just in case. I can
remember, they had the police with all the horses in the bullpen.
Gooden was throwing to me and every time the ball would hit the glove,
you'd have the horses getting jumpy (laughs). Oh, hell man, then the
miracle happened. That series was sort of the highlight of my
career. Didn't get to perform in it, but I played a very, very small
part on some pretty good teams.
RG: That was a time in baseball where
many of the off the field temptations seemed bigger than ever and
grabbed some guys' careers by the throat. Did you sort of have to
push those temptations aside. There was all sorts of things going on
in the early '80s. (The Star's baseball writer Mark Zwolinski) talks
about his couple of years in the Mets farm system being unusual and
exciting...
JG: Yeah, I didn't know he was (in the
Mets system) until you told me that at the winter meetings.
RG: Yeah, Dr. (Ron) Taylor scouted him for the Mets.
JG: Is that right? I'll be damned. He
never mentioned a word about that.
RG: He never does.
JG: Yeah, (as far as the partying) I
was a nobody and in a lot of ways I'm a loner. I keep to myself. It
wasn't like I had earned anything to be in the middle of that team. I
was a part of it, but I wasn't an integral part of it. So, I just
kind of kept to myself, did my own thing. Back then, in the olden
days, you had to earn your stripes. Nowadays everybody just kind of
hits it from Day 1, even if you're not. So I kind of kept to myself.
On the outside, you witness a lot of crazy stuff. That was a wild
bunch.
3-DISAPPOINTING PLAYING CAREER LEADS TO CAREER IN COACHING
RG: The experience of not going on to
establish the career that people expected obviously doesn't mean that you
weren't paying attention, because you did manage in the Mets farm
system afterwards and you've managed twice now for the Jays. Did you
realize at the time, that you were in fact paying attention to
details, to guys like Davey Johnson, maybe for a future role. You have mentioned Johnson as a major influence as a manager. Did you
consciously pay attention to detail or was it just something that you
absorbed?
JG: I'm one of those guys. As a catcher
you've got to pay attention day-to-day. But consciously, I don't
think I was sitting there going, I want to manage in the big leagues,
I've got to pay attention to what this guy's doing. No, but you can
tell who's got it, who doesn't. The thing I got most from Davey is
Davey's a very confident guy, I'm sure you know that. The players
picked up on that. That helped those guys getting to the task.
He believed in it and that's kind of
what rubbed off on me. He's very smart, always on the ball. He let
you do your thing. He didn't talk very often directly to a player. He
very often came through a coach, especially for the young guys. But
there was something about him, this guy's on the ball. That was kind
of it. But I don't really remember noticing, saying 'God, that's what
I want to be.' I thought I wanted to get into coaching, but it could
have been high school, it could have been college, it could have been
professional. But, at that time it was sort of open.
RG: But those attributes that Davey
has, of never letting your players see you react, never showing your
players when you're behind, staying on an even keel when times are
tough in a game...
JG: Yeah, that's him.
RG: Communicating with players, not
necessarily face-to-face. I mean you're going to have to do a lot of
that with the number of Latin players this year to get the proper
message across.
That's something you said Davey already
did. Being in charge, letting guys play the game, just get out of the
way, you've said that's one of your attributes. Are you just putting
guys out there letting them play the game? Is it your goal to just
not get in the way?
JG: I think so. The biggest mistake
people make in this game is they try to control too many things. As a
manager you have your job. You have to run the pitching staff, the
bullpen and all that. There's got to be some structure there. You
call the shifts, but, eventually, guys that are control freaks, it
catches up with them. The players are the show. When you bring in the
type of players we've got this year, guys that have been successful,
there's a reason they're successful. You've got to let them do their
thing.
RG: Is it easier to manage that way,
let them play, easier when you have a very talented team compared to a very mediocre team? Just observing Cito (Gaston), those '92-'93 teams are
relatively like the team you have this year. But then later on, in
the mid-to-late-'90s, Cito, the same manager, was given younger teams that didn't
already know how to play. He wasn't able to perform the same magic
with those groups. Do you agree that with a team that's talented and
self-motivated it's easier for the description you've
given.
JG: Everybody wants to manage a team
they don't have to coach so much. It makes things easier.
RG: Hey skip, stay out da way.
JG: Yeah. It's the old 'push-button'
club. I don't mind people saying that, we've got a push-button club.
That's great. As long as you're winning.
RG: Was it different the first time
(with the Jays), because those weren't push-button clubs.
JG: I wouldn't say that. We had some
very talented guys. I don't want to say something was missing, but
there just wasn't enough with us to get over the hump. Whatever the
expectations were, we went into a couple of years expecting a lot,
whether that was legit or not. Sometimes you think you're better than
you are.
There were some times we achieved our level. There were
times we underachieved too. We hung in there, but to be honest with
you, I don't know if there was enough to get over the hump. We had
the Yankees and Red Sox, the way they were built. That's not an
excuse, taking the easy way out on my part, but that's the way it
was.
4- “NOT MY JOHN GIBBONS”: DAVEY JOHNSON
RG: I don't know if you've ever heard
the story. When you got named to replace Carlos Tosca, it was an
Olympic year. It was Athens, the end of '04. Davey Johnson was an
adviser for Team Netherlands.
JG: Yeah, I remember reading that.
RG: The news came out over there that
you had taken over. His reaction was, 'Not my John Gibbons!!??'
JG: (laughs, laughs again) He said that. (laughs
again)
RG: Do you find it humourous that Davey
would say that spontaneously?
JG: Yeah.
RG: Like you said, you weren't
necessarily sitting next to him in the (Mets) dugout...
JG: I rarely got on the field and when
I would do anything it would be down there warming up in the pen. And
let's face it, you don't get recognized in this business until you've
accomplished something. If you're successful as a player, it carries
some weight, it buys you some time. If you haven't accomplished
anything, you get the shot but then if you don't do anything great,
everybody and their brother in the baseball world is going, 'How did
this guy get that job?' You know how it is.
So, I mean it doesn't surprise me (with
Davey). I had some good people on the way that gave me some
opportunities, you know. Let's be realistic. The odds of coming back
here a second time, you gotta have a charmed life in some ways. But that is kind of funny.
5-FAMOUS CONFLICTS WITH JAYS PLAYERS
RG: The other thing that I wanted to
know, if you found surprising, was when Brendan Kennedy called Shea
Hillenbrand after you got the job, he was totally complimentary and
wished you the best and thought you were a great person, a people
manager and stuff like that. Does that surprise you?
JG: It shocked me 'cuz I read it, but
the point is that Shea and I had a pretty good relationship from the
get-go, when he first showed up. I had great respect for him. I knew
he had some problems (with the Red Sox) in the past. But with us
early on, everything was fine. He was a big part at first. He played
very well for us. Then the thing with playing time (in the field at
third and first) when we got Troy Glaus and Lyle Overbay. I mean that
soured him. But you know there's nothing you can do about it. That's
the way it was set up. Those guys were our position players. Things
happened and things came to a head. I hadn't run into him since, but
to read that it kind of shocked me a little. I didn't know how he was
going to react. He didn't have to say it, but it was pretty nice.
RG: You also weren't big on
Hillenbrand's 'country-club' comment (at spring training '06) when he
said there was too much of a country club atmosphere.
JG: You know, every spring training
I've been at, whether it's the Mets or the minor leagues, you get to
a certain level, a certain point in the game and – I don't want to
say it's a country club, but baseball is a relaxed, get-after-it type
game. It's not football where you're beating people down, rah-rah
type. Country club? I don't really understand what that means. The
manager's not sitting there screaming and yelling, 'Go run a lap, you
missed a ball.'
RG: I agree. I remember as late as '72,
guys would show up to spring training totally out of shape. They
needed spring training for that. These days, they come up and the
first day they're throwing 90 miles-an-hour in the pen. So, like, now
you have them do their work and then they go home.
JG: You know what I've always believed,
too. I tell the players I've been with whether it's managing in the
minors or the big leagues, 'Hey, if you've got a beef, got a problem,
come see me. Let's hash this thing out. You know you may be right.'
The back-biting and the bullshit, that
get's you nowhere. (The player) might be right. Even sometimes as
coaches, you get blinded to some things. You're doing the same things
over and over. Somebody might have something to say. You know what,
we're a little lax, we need to push this, push that. I have no
problem with that, but take your shots elsewhere. You come and see me
first.
RG: At what point during the (Ted
Lilly) pitching change did you decide that you were going to go down
the tunnel.
JG: It was kind of just a reaction
thing. I got to the mound, Ted wouldn't give me the ball. He was
barking. We were barking a little bit back and forth. He gave the
ball and then we kind of bumped on the way off. So I was walking off
the mound and I just looked into the dugout – there's stairs going
up to the clubhouse – and he's just standing there and he was going
back and forth like a shooting range with a duck, or something.
That's what I remember. I just walked there.
RG: So you saw him as you were coming
off the field.
JG: Yeah. It wasn't like pre-meditated
on the mound saying, 'I'm going to get that sucker,' you know. It was
like I walked down (the tunnel) and he said something to me first and
I said something to him. We were grabbing each other and that was
that.
6-FIRED FOR THE FIRST TIME; STAYS BUSY BETWEEN JAYS STINTS
RG: When J.P. decided to replace you
with Cito -- and at one point much earlier, J.P. had said when he
gave you the extension, if you weren't managing the Jays, there'd be
seven or eight teams lining up to hire you -- do you think that
reputation as a hothead made it seem, in your mind, that you were
going to be a one-and-done kind of manager. Like you talked about
earlier, guys that get one chance then gone.
JG: I figured that's not going to help
me. When you get fired and you're seen as carrying some baggage now,
regardless of how it got there, it's going to be tough.
I've never been one of those guys. I
love this profession. I love managing, but I wasn't obsessed that
I've got to manage. I'm content. I always believe that if your
reputation is good out there and the right thing opens up, somebody
will give you a shot.
I'm never one to pursue things to
promote myself. I'm not good at that. But, yeah, your first shot,
you're nobody, no name, if you get to the post-season that carries a
lot of weight. It can carry you for the rest of your career. That
didn't happen, so (in your own mind) there may not be another shot.
Then I got the bench job (with the Royals) and I was very, very happy
with that.
RG: How did the bench job come about?
Were you interested in a managing job in the time after you left the
Jays? Did you ever apply for anything after you left the Jays?
JG: I was fired in June ('08) and at
the beginning of September I started calling different teams. I
talked to a couple of GMs directly and then I left some messages. But
I basically said, 'You know if you have any openings on the staff,
I'd like to throw my name in there. I'm not looking for anybody's
job, but if something comes up, what have you.'
Trey Hillman was managing the Royals.
His bench coach was Dave Owen. He didn't really have much coaching
experience. So they were looking to change it. I knew Trey. It's like
DeMarlo Hale. We all managed together coming up through the minor
leagues. Fellow Texan, that ain't all bad. He called and said,
'Listen, we're going to put our bench coach over at third base, why
don't you come in for an interview.' It was kind of a natural fit. We
knew each other. He went through a tough year and he probably wanted
somebody that he knew. So, they called and I met with Trey and Dayton
Moore at the airport in Austin (TX). We sat down for an hour and that
was when he called me and said do you want the job? Knowing him in
the past, that's big. That put it over and, I'll tell you, I had a
blast doing it (for three years).
RG: Do you think that Royals job kept
you in the public eye enough that when Alex was looking again...do
you think it was important that you had that major-league bench coach
stint?
JG: Yeah. Just being out of the
major-leagues for one year is probably pushing the limit. I could go
back and I'm managing here in San Antonio for a second year, you know
that. But maybe, you might not be able to sell yourself next year,
you know what I mean. You've got to be around (the major leagues). If
it's the other way you get lost in it.
RG: San Antonio could have been like
coming home for good. When Felipe Alou was passed over when the Expos
hired Buck Rodgers (in '85), at that point, Felipe said, OK, I'm
still in the organization but you're obviously not interested in me
as a (major-league) manager, so have me manage in the Florida State
League. I live in West Palm. Have me manage West Palm. I'll be at
home. When you said at your (Blue Jays) press conference that San
Antonio was your dream job, was that in your thinking, that I might
as well manage at home if I'm going to do anything.
JG: Yeah. You know, what happened...you
know how you drag, you bat things around when you're young, not a
whole lot of stability. They won't say it, but they get tired of that
too. As you get a little older at this point last year, my middle
son's going off to college next year. I'm not going to have much time
left with him. When I got cut loose at Kansas City, if this job was
open and I heard it was, I thought I'd love to do that, go home for a
year, maybe two. I had my 10 years (service time) in, so the pension
was set. Things were good. I pursued that.
If that hadn't happened, I had talked
to Toronto about a fulltime scouting job. I talked to other teams
about scouting, roving type jobs, so I was perfectly content with
that. I didn't give much thought that this may be it for me. I better
not do this, but I understood that that was possibly the case.
7-QUE SERA SERA CAREER -- BLOND AMBITION
RG: I'd like to do a small exercise
with you. I have a list here of John Gibbons post-playing career jobs
that you have had. If you could respond whether you applied for each
one or not.
JG: OK. I can do that.
RG: Jays bullpen catcher.
JG: No.
RG: Jays first base coach.
JG: No.
RG: Jays manager – first time.
JG: No.
RG: The contract extension with J.P.
JG: No.
RG: You didn't demand an extension?
JG: No (laughs).
RG: Royals' bench coach.
JG: Yes.
RG: San Antonio manager.
JG: Yes, I had a couple of people call
(the Padres).
RG: This time around as Jays manager.
JG: No.
RG: That's pretty good. That's a pretty
good record of landing on your feet.
JG: Yeah. You know that (Jays) bullpen
catching job. When (J.P.) got the (Jays' GM) job, he was helping make
calls for me because I'd walked away from the Mets and the Triple-A
team because I wanted to get closer to home with my family. I would
have taken an A-ball job, anything.
RG: So you just didn't go back to the
Mets (after '01). You didn't want to be there anymore.
JG: Yeah, I'd been with the Mets as
Triple-A manager for three years. (Bobby) Valentine was managing at
that time. Every year they were going through at least one coach,
maybe two. I didn't get one of the jobs and, I mean, that's the way
it goes. He wanted one of his people. But usually a Triple-A manager
slides in there after a few years. That didn't happen.
So, I applied again that following year
after the 2001 season. I think Valentine was looking for a third-base
coach. They called and said, we don't need an interview. We
interviewed the year before. Then I didn't get it, so I told them,
you know what, I'm going to move on. It's time. It's no big deal.
(Mets beat writer) Marty Noble called me and wrote an article and
(GM) Steve Phillips called me the day after it came out and said 'I
think we definitely need to part ways.' I told him, 'Well I told you
that' (laughs).
Billy Beane was out in Oakland and he
always told me when I was in the Mets system as a coach, to keep in
touch. He said if you ever want to come over and are looking for a
job, just let me know. So I thought that was my ace in the hole. But
around this time (when I quit), I hadn't even checked with him. He
told me and I didn't think he was bullshitting me.
They were having some success at the
time. I can remember with J.P. (an assistant at the time to Beane
with the A's), they were in New York playing the Yankees in the
playoffs and I walked up and said, 'Do you guys have anything over
there?' And he goes, 'No, we don't' (JG laughs). I thought, well, OK. So J.P. started making some calls
around the game for me. Nothing broke.
Let's see, I had two weeks left on my
contract with the Mets. I had been living in New Mexico for a couple
of years and had just moved back to San Antonio. I had three kids and
just bought a new house and had two weeks left on my job. So, yeah, I
needed to find something.
One day I called Beane and he told me,
'Hey, I'll call you back. J.P.'s having a press conference (in
Toronto).' That's when (Ricciardi) got (the Toronto) job out of the
blue. My thought was, you know he's been trying to help me find a
job, he should at least have something over here for me. I don't know
what it is but I need something. So, he called me back and he said,
'Hey, listen, we've got the third base coaching job here and the
bullpen catcher.' I don't even remember if he said bullpen catcher
right away. He said, 'I'm bringing in Carlos Tosca up here.' They had
a connection from the Yankees. He said come on up and interview. I
said alright.
So I went up there and met with him and Buck Martinez.
At the end of the interview they say, 'Well we have the bullpen
catching job. Do you have any interest there?' I said, 'No I can't do
that.' I'm going a little better than that. Right then I realized,
well, they've already settled on this (as the best offer). There goes
my coaching interview. So I get home and I'm thinking, damn, you know
I need a joB. I've got 10 days left. So, I called him back.”
RG: Basically at the time you would
have qualified as a minority hire in that you're an idiot for
quitting your Mets job before you had another one lined up.
JG: (laughs) Exactly. So I call him
back and I say, hey, you know what, the more I think about it, it
makes sense. I've spent my whole life as a bullpen catcher and now
I'm going to do it again. So, he gave me that job. I go to spring
training – I haven't squatted in 10 years – the first day my knee
breaks down. So now I'm the only bullpen catcher in the big leagues
that can't catch. I remember Greg Myers was there. He was ragging me
too. Tom Wilson and those guys.
Honest to God, I'd be down in the
bullpen catching, once the season starts and it's, man, we've got 10
guys (warming) up every game. We're getting beat down pretty good.
Nobody can get anybody out and my knee's killing me. I'm catching on
one knee. I thought, I might not be able to make it to June. I can't
do this. Maybe I should get into scouting. I may have to go to J.P.
and say something. Then June came around. He ended up firing Buck and
putting in Tosca to manage. I took over at first base. That's how it
all started. It was a relief physically and professionally.
RG: The good thing is you didn't have
to go to one knee too often coaching first base.
JG: Yeah.
8-DEVELOPING KEY RELATIONSHIPS FOR THE FUTURE WITH METS
RG: When all you guys were coming up as
prospects through the Mets organization, there's all sorts of random
stories about who was playing with who in the New York-Penn League.
JG: That was Beane and J.P.
RG: Beane and J.P. and then...
JG: 1980
RG: Were you and J.P. on the same team
at one point?
JG: In '81, Shelby, North Carolina.
RG: But it wasn't New York-Penn?
JG: No, that was a short-season draft
year. I don't remember exactly how it happened, but J.P. eventually
ended up with the Yankees. I think that's how he connected with
Tosca. But then, I didn't hear from him or see him for years. I was
roving (instructor) around '90 with the Mets as a catching guy. I'm
in the Boston airport, I'm walking through Logan and I come to the
gate and J.P.'s sitting there. He's going down to scout some player
in Richmond, Virginia, I'm going to Norfolk. We sat next to each
other on the plane, got to talking and I want to say we kept in touch
a little bit after that.
But I hadn't seen him in a while and
when he became Beane's righthand man we talked a few times. Then he
actually came when I was managing the Mets' Triple-A team, he came to
town to watch a couple of players. (The A's) were making the trade
for (Jason) Isringhausen for Billy Taylor. So he came to watch (outfielder)
Terence Long who was on my team. We got together and it was like old
times.
9-GIBBY'S DEVELOPING RELATIONSHIP WITH ALEX
RG: Alex told me when he was an assistant
GM that he'd go down...and I even remember him on trips that he went
on -- he would hang around the coaches room and this and that.
Obviously, he was paying attention too, but are you surprised at how
adamant he is at how strong he is in publicly backing you and your player
evaluation ability and the (personnel) suggestions you've made that
he knows about and how he says they've always been bang-on? Did you
realize that talent evaluation was one of your strengths?
JG: You never know. I've always
believed that you tell it like you see it. You don't ride the fence
and give the easy answers. That mainly stays within the organization stuff that I've mentioned. When he's asking about outside guys, I
don't see that as much. It's a crapshoot anyways, but you just do what you can and hope you're right on. You don't stick your neck out for
guys unless you believe they can do something. It's easy to (go with
the crowd) when everybody else is against something. If you back (a
player), he better do it or he may never get another shot. Who knows
if you're going to be right. I thought I could evaluate decently,
but you're lucky if you're right half the time anyway.
RG: Did you think, in hindsight, after
you got the manager's) job in November, that Alex knew something
ahead of time. It's kind of unusual for a GM to ask someone to fly up
just for an advance scout job or a bench coach job without having a
manager in place yet. In hindsight, did you think maybe he had an
idea about you as manager?
JG: No, he's so tightlipped nobody
knows. What I thought was happening was he committed to a veteran
manager, a guy with some experience and I thought, well you know he's
not matching up with a guy, whoever he's looking at. It's not
working, so he might have to go back to one of the young
(candidates), the inexperienced guys. This might be my chance to, you
know, I wouldn't have minded, I wouldn't have had any problem being a
coach.
RG: A bench coach.
JG: Yeah. You like to be in positions
where you can call your own shots and of course the money's good, but
I'm not so stuck on myself that you've got to be the guy.
10-HANDLING A DIVERSE BLUE JAYS CLUBHOUSE
RG: Again, this question comes down to,
completely going back to your youth growing up, but it seems that
there's not one prejudgmental bone in your body in terms of dealing
with a diversity of players, dealing with Latin kids,
African-Americans. I mean you grew up in the deep south in the '60s
and '70s where that (tolerance) wasn't always the case, societally. Who do you
credit for your even-handed vision of race and of handling the people
that you are around?
JG: Some of my best friends have always
been minorities. There's a big Mexican community down here. We're all
the same. We're all equal. We just look different. But you know my
mom and dad, I don't remember them saying anything, but they managed
to keep their kids level-headed and appreciative of what they have,
that they're no different than that other guy.
RG: Does athletics play a part in
acceptance?
JG: No doubt. It's kind of the way we
were brought up, with my friends.
11-COULD HAVE BEEN A LONGHORN WITH CLEMENS
RG: Was your high school experience
good for you in terms of developing who you are today, or was it a
tough time in your life? Did you have college options.
JG: Yeah, I was going to go to the
University of Texas to play. I actually would have been up there with
Roger Clemens. I talked to Oklahoma, Oklahoma St., Stanford, those
kind of places. When (Longhorns head coach) Cliff Gustafson called, he never saw me play but
he had scouts who told him, hey we've got this kid down here. He
offered me a scholarship. I was going to be there. But I wanted to
get into pro ball. Something was drawing me. Then, when I had a
chance to be a first-round pick. That helped.
RG: When you came back home after your
first pro year, was it hard when you came back and you're hanging
around with the same kids that you went to high school with to stay
level-headed with all that pro money. How much of a bonus did you
get?
JG: Fifty-five (thousand). Straw was
picked No. 1 and he got $230,000 I think. Beane, who was picked right
in front of me, got $130,000. (Pitcher) Jay Tibbs, who was picked
(first by the Mets in Round 2 got like $90,000. I signed in three
days. Those guys all signed in the middle of June, July or something.
I couldn't believe it. I asked them and they all got the same first
offer – 45 grand.
After the scout drafted me to the Mets
– he came to the Blue Jays later, his name was Jim Hughes – so I
don't know, if he got fired for signing me or got a big promotion
from the Blue Jays (laughs).
The Blue Jays had come around and gave
me a private tryout at my high school. (Fellow San Antonio native Jays scout) Al LaMacchia would have been there, but they
brought some other guy. They came here and gave me a tryout, then
they went to Austin, same thing for Kelly Gruber. There were four or
five guys they were looking at. It was kind of that group they were
looking at and the settled on (shortstop) Garry Harris.
RG: (laughs) It shows you the imprecise
nature of scouting.
JG: Yeah, you're right.
RG: Thanks John and good luck.
Recent Comments