Today's feature by Susan Pigg about television's affect on baby brains has inspired a rigorous debate among commenters.
It cites long-term research that correlates an increase in television watching with the prevalence of attention disorders, such as ADHD.
What do you think?
Here's my take. Yes, there is an abundance of television programming geared at getting those who are still on the boob into the tube. But at the same time, this is the age of hyper-parenting, at least among relatively affluent social stratas, where you'd be hard-pressed to make the point that kids are babysat by television. On the contrary, they're likely carted around to Gymboree and parent-and-tot music and introduction to origami.
If anything, companies like Baby Einstein have capitalized on the whole "Years before five..."/"Mozart effect" phenomenon by convincing consumers that they're actually giving their children a leg up in life by exposing them to colours, numbers, the alphabet, in DVD form, all while they're still in nappies. They're tapping into a marketplace that would rather know what they're putting into the DVD player than pop their kids in front of whatever is on Treehouse.
I guess what would be dangerous is lulling ourselves into a false sense of the enrichment that so-called "educational" programs provide. A baby's best entertainment is the face of a parent or other loving caregiver, so substituting hours and hours of tri-lingual puppets for old-fashioned interaction would be a shame. It's likely the most isolated parents — with fewer resources for classes — that are most likely to lean heavily on these products.
But every so often, we all need a little help from Treehouse or TVOkids or Baby Einstein. I wish I could say that I never get to a point on a long, cold January Sunday afternoon when we've all been cooped up inside and say, both boys have suddenly gotten bloody noses at the exact same time (separate incidents - true story), and I'm tired of plucking my toddler off the dining room table. Those are moments when I'm going to say yes to TV or a short DVD. Because they seem to need some "down time," as my five-year-old has taken to spinning it, and we need them to leave us alone for five minutes so we can do the dishes or shower and stuff. (And if I can get through a cup of tea without having to warm it up twice in the microwave, that is a complete luxury for me.)
My takeaway from this is pretty commonsense: don't think of educational programs like a visit from the Mensa fairy, use them — and all kids' TV — in moderation, and make sure your kids get exercise. Then, when you do plunk in the Backyardigans as an alternative to losing your temper or crying more piteously than the baby, do it without guilt.
Recent Comments