If you're saving Thursday's Idol results show to view later, you don't want to be reading this post.
I was one of the dozens of bloggers and journalists on the phone today with the four people who were voted off Idol after this first week of performances. And seriously, what a cheery upbeat bunch.
I realize nobody wants to get on the phone with the media after elimination and spout sour grapes, but Janell Wheeler especially was like a ray of sunshine on a dreary winter day.
Janell, 24, who lives in Tampa, Fla., (right) said she had a feeling on Thursday she was going to be voted off, but "I'm doing good. I'm doing better than people would think."
For one thing, she's proud of the way she handled herself when Ryan Seacrest gave her the bad news.
"Several of the girls texted me and said, 'Janell, you had so much poise. You were a class act.' "
She also feels she sang "What About Love" better Thursday than she had on the performance show.
"I don't know how I could have a better experience than I did," she added. "I have no hard feelings. I'm so supportive of everyone else in the cast. I think I'm going to go on and be part of this family for a very long time. I'm so happy to have represented America even if it was just for one week."
All four of the castoffs are planning to pursue careers in music. Janell hopes to leave her mark on country music and head to Nashville. Ashley Rodriguez, 22, of Chelsea, Maine, (right) vowed that "America will get to see me again." Joe Munoz, 20, of Huntington Park, Calif., would like to record pop music but also get into musical theatre and television. He mentioned a couple of Canadians, Michael Buble and Celine Dion, as artists he admires.
Tyler Grady, 20, of Nazareth, Penn., dropped the name of his band, Wailing Waters, so often it got kind of comical. He hopes to record an album with the band and hopes fans who appreciated him on Idol will transfer their allegiance to the group.
Tyler was keen to emphasize that he's not bitter about his Idol experience. When he commented on Thursday's show that he didn't get much constructive criticism from the judges, he wasn't disrespecting them, he said, just standing up for himself.
A lot of the questions for him during the conference call had to do with seemingly conflicting advice from the judges, praising his '70s vibe during Hollywood Week but then attacking it during the performance show.
Tyler (right) was adamant he wouldn't have changed his style had he lasted another week, although he might have picked a more modern rock song to sing (his Wednesday choice was the Guess Who's "American Woman.")
"You do need to stick to your guns as a performer. You have to be true to yourself. Honesty as a performer is everything," he said.
"There's no better school for the entertainment industry than American Idol," he added. "We literally had the best of the best, as far as the band, backup singers, the production crew..."
All of the contestants mentioned some of the stresses of the experience. Tyler said it was stressful performing on television (I never got a chance to ask him to expand on that). Janell mentioned the difficulty of getting used to the stage and the way the band sounded in that environment. Ashley mentioned how nervous everyone had been performing live on TV for the first time. Joe (below right) mentioned how nervewracking it was standing onstage with Tim Urban, waiting to learn which one of them would be eliminated.
"I was blocking myself from even listening because I didn't want to get more nervous than I already was."
There were lots of questions about the judges' critiques, which some observers have described as harsher than usual.
"I think a lot of people thought they would be a little lenient considering it was our first live show, but it turns out they were coming throwing punches.... I wouldn't say they were too hard, but definitely we could have used a little love from them," said Ashley. "At the end of the day, I love them all. They've played such a huge role in this experience for me."
It certainly sounded like the good outweighed the bad, even for the short time the four of them got to be on the show.
Janell talked about the friends she's made from being on the show and the fact the experience has encouraged her to devote her life to music.
"Idol has given me a little taste of the dream and I'm willing to work hard for it," said Ashley. She said the top 24 photo shoot was one of her favourite experiences - "It was just super glamorous" - and also mentioned working with Ricky Minor and the band, the wonderful fans she's gained and friendships with girls like Janell and Michelle Delamor.
She said she has no regrets, a statement echoed by Joe. "I've been pretty comfortable with all the decisions I've made. I'm pretty happy with what I did. I'm pretty proud of myself," he said.
Recent Comments