Turns out the "dumb blond" was smarter than he looked.
Fabio, a.k.a. Jud Birza, 21, won the $1 million prize and title of "sole survivor" on Survivor: Nicaragua on Sunday night. 
And thank goodness he did. It would have been a pretty boring finale had Chase, Sash and Holly enacted their plan to oust Fabio and then Dan, and romped unopposed to the final three.
Fabio thwarted their scheme by winning the last two immunity challenges, leading to Dan's elimination. Then he proved he was more than just a pretty face by playing with his head instead of his heart and taking Chase and Sash to the final with him.
Chase did give him a run for the money, but I figured Fabio's win was pretty much a done deal when he broke down talking about his mom and jury members could be seen wiping away their own tears.
Here's how it went down. Day 37 unspooled with Fabio trying to find a way to convince Sash and Chase to take him to the final three, while they plotted with Holly to get rid of him if he didn't win immunity.
The challenge involved racing to a station to answer questions about Nicaragua, choosing between one of two replies, and then racing back to the start with bags of puzzle pieces; whether the puzzle pieces were real or fakes covered in black depended on how the questions were answered. It took three bags of them to solve the puzzle, which depicted the Survivor logo.
By rights, Fabio should have lost. He was way behind after answering a question incorrectly. But he ended up neck in neck with Sash and beat him with just seconds to spare.
Fabio got to work back at camp, trying to save his alliance-mate Dan, and to convince Sash and Chase that Holly was a bigger threat in the final three and should be voted out. He got nowhere with Chase, but Sash seemed to be coming around, noting that Holly was the only woman left in the game and might draw votes from the predominantly female jury.
Even host Jeff Probst seemed to be on board with the "Holly is a bigger threat" theme at tribal council.
Dan argued that because he already had money no one was going to vote to give him the million, but Holly would appear more sympathetic, coming from a small town of 1,100 in South Dakota.
Holly vehemently disagreed and said Dan should be judged on "has he been aggressive, has he gone out and talked to people, has he made the right alliances?"
"Holly, those attributes you mention, those all seem to make the argument to take him to the end. He hasn't done anything to earn the money, which is Dan's point exactly," Jeff said.
Fabio noted that Holly was a motherly figure respected by a lot of the women on the jury.
"That's a compliment to Holly, she's a pretty cool lady," he added.
"It's a compliment, but it's also a warning, Holly," said Jeff before calling the vote.
After all that, it was a mild surprise when Dan had his torch snuffed instead of Holly. Even Fabio voted against him.
Dan minced no words in his post-snuff confessional.
"I switched my vote tonight to Chase to tell him how much I dislike the guy. I want nothing to do with you. Holly, you're a crook. You stole my shoes. They ought to cut your damn hands off. Sash, you're just like a whiny little girl, unh, unh, unh, and you're a liar. I wish them the worst and I can't wait to cast my vote."
Wow Dan, tell us how you really feel.
For the final four back at camp, it was business as usual: Holly, Chase and Sash plotting to get rid of Fabio, Fabio fretting about what would happen if he didn't win immunity again.
And then came the part of the show I hate the most: the cheesy paying tribute to fallen tribemates part. This time, the finalists had to gather shields with past castaways' names on them and then burn them while pretending to think fond thoughts of people whom, in some cases, they barely knew.
The only fun part of the exercise was when they got to the shields with NaOnka's and Purple Kelly's names and had nothing to say about them other than them being quitters.
"Eleven days left, to walk out of the game it's definitely disappointing," Holly said of NaOnka.
"Ah, another quitter," said Fabio, as they came upon Kelly's shield.
In her voiceover, Kelly at least sounded embarrassed about walking away. Na just bragged about how she always had a smile and was friendly (huh?), was the smartest player in the game (as if) and the craziest (yeah, I'll give you that).
It was on to the final immunity challenge, in which the players had to balance a sword vertically against a shield and use the other hand to stack coins with uneven surfaces on the handle.
Once again, Fabio looked like he was going to lose as his stack of coins tilted precariously. And then, just like that, Sash's stack fell and Fabio won his third straight immunity and his spot in the final three.
"I expect a very interesting afternoon back at camp," said Jeff with his talent for understatement.
I must say it did my heart good to see Sash and Chase scrambling to curry favour with Fabio.
"I feel like you're my best friend in the game," avowed Sash. "I guarantee, I promise you I've never said that to anyone else here. I'm serious."
"Cool," said a smirking Fabio, who didn't believe a word of it.
Sash also pointed out how many votes he suspected Chase would get from the jury, a conversation that Fabio duly reported to Chase.
"I'm pissed Sash went behind my back and tried to get me out," fumed Chase. "Sash will do whatever it takes to get himself further in the game ... he's definitely a snake."
Then he promptly ratted out Sash for wanting to vote off Fabio.
"Its like I turned on the light and all these little cockroaches are trying to scramble to get out of the way to throw somebody else under the bus, you know," said a gleeful Fabio.
Holly at least came clean and admitted that yes, she would have voted Fabio off if he hadn't won immunity.
"Sash and Chase lied to me the whole time, saying they would take me to the final three," said Fabio. "Holly is the only one who hasn't lied."
But honesty wasn't a good enough reason to take her to the final three, not after factoring in who would get the most jury votes.
Holly's post-torch-snuff confessional presented a stark contrast to Dan's.
"On Day 5, I wanted to walk away from this game. Here I am making it through Day 38, so never give up. One thing I know is that my family and my true friends back home are going to be truly proud of me," she said, with nary of mention of wanting anyone's hands cut off.
Back at camp, on the final day, there was lots of fake bonhomie as the final three shared a breakfast of pancakes and bread and jam and juice together, but Sash didn't think his two "wingmen" deserved to be in the final three and Chase was hoping that telling Fabio he was going to win would make him overconfident.
I was happy to see one change at the final tribal. Each player got an opening statement and answered questions, but there was no closing statement.
Chase took the "it's been an honour to play the game with you" route and welcomed the jurors' questions, even the ones who were pissed with him, because "I will be completely honest and tell you exactly what happened."
Fabio concentrated on his immunity wins and the fact he hadn't backstabbed anyone, then got the jurors laughing by saying, "I just think I deserve a million dollars. I could have a lot of fun."
Sash tried the "it was only a game" gambit. "I want everyone to know that friendships I formed I take much more seriously than the actual alliances. Sorry if some of the alliances were broken. That was part of the game and I hope you respect me for that."
But it quickly became apparent that not everybody did.
"Sash, all I have to say is somebody sure as hell raised you good to be a New York City river rat," spat Jane. "As far as I'm concerned, you can go back to the New York City gutters and crawl back into the black hole you came from."
"Sash, through the entire game, I was able to see through the fake smile, the uh huh uh huh laugh," said Benry.
"Sash, you're a liar, you're a phony, you said things to me that you never lived up to," said Dan. "I think you're spineless and I hate that smile and I think that if I were you I'd go to the doctor tomorrow to get that eye fixed" to stop the wink.
Dan also had bitter words for Chase: "A lot of people are bleeding here because of you. You backstabbed everybody, you backstabbed me, you backstabbed Jane, who was your right-hand person. You really let people down. You let me down tremendously. I'm gonna tell you something: beauty fades, dumb is forever."
Marty was also down on Chase, challenging him to pick a player other than Marty who should win the "dumber than a bag of hammers award."
"It's a b.s. question because I can't pick you," said Chase.
Moving on, Marty said, "Sash, I think you're a cerebral player. Chase, that means smart." Marty also praised Fabio, saying, "Dude, I think you changed the most as a person and as a player."
Benry was another non-Chase fan, telling him dismissively, "Chase, I think I've heard everything I need to hear from you tonight." He congratulated Fabio for playing a "savage game."
Chase got some love from Jane, oddly enough, despite having thrown her under the bus. "Even though I'm totally pissed at you, you did make my time out here the funnest time I ever had," Jane told him before lobbing a softball question about what he would do with the million dollars.
Chase said he'd give $100,000 to a cancer charity started by his brother called Hunt the Cure and take care of his mom, which spurred Fabio to pipe up that he'd take care of his mom and dad, too.
Fabio's softball question came from, of all people, NaOnka (guess she wasn't kidding when she told me they were really friends).
"Fabio, it's been a pleasure cussing you out," Na said, calling Fabio her "hippie friend."
She asked him whether seeing his mother at the previous reward challenge had been the gasoline Fabio needed to win three back-to-back immunity challenges.
"Yeah, man, it got me to the end, yeah," said Fabio tearfully. "That's just something inside you that comes out when it's necessary. I never felt like that before in my life." Benry and others wiped away tears.
But then along came Alina to kill the buzz. "Dude, I don't really want to give a million dollars to a boy, I want to give a million dollars to a man," she told Fabio.
Her questions had Fabio, Chase and Sash arguing with each other about who outwitted and outplayed who, whether Fabio had been as clueless as he seemed about some of the votes at tribal council and whether Chase was wishy washy.
"I like that this is two, maybe three men fighting for what they want," said Alina cheerfully.
Not surprisingly, Alina voted for Chase to win. "You impressed me tonight. You came in here like somebody I have never seen before. You had your game face on," she said after casting her vote.
Brenda also voted for Chase.
Marty said, "Chase is the dumbest player ever to play this game and Sash is a weasel. Fabio, man, I love you and I loved your game. I believed everything you said tonight. You were awesome."
Fabio also got NaOnka's and Dan's votes.
Is anybody surprised that Sash got not a single vote? In the end, Fabio took five votes to Chase's four.
He told Jeff on the reunion show he'll use his cash to start a production company focused on music and ethnicology. And yes, he's still using the name Fabio.
Some other highlights from the reunion show:
nChase said there was nothing going on between Brenda and him; they're just good friends.
nChase, who's trying to break into country music, sang a song (well, that wasn't really a highlight for me, I hate country music).
nTerry Bradshaw appeared to talk about his friend Jimmy Johnson and how "I was worried he was going to kill himself ... they got him off before he hurt himself."
nHolly and Dan literally kissed and made up after she gave him a pair of cowboy boots to make up for the alligator shoes she dumped in the ocean. And she got to keep her hands. Dan wouldn't answer Jeff's question about how rich he actually is.
nJane won the $100,000 fan-voted Sprint Player of the Season award. She and Marty definitely did not make up. Asked by Jeff if they'd become friends, Marty answered, "Not so much."
nNaOnka repeated her claim that how she played the game should not be confused with her real life, but even her mother, Zena, said she was surprised by what she saw her daughter doing week after week. "NaOnka, your mom just threw you under the bus," Jeff said.
nJeff announced a new rule inspired by Na and Purple Kelly whereby the producers get to decide whether a player who quits should be on the jury.
nShannon was given a chance to redeem himself for calling Sash gay at an early tribal council and instead dug an even bigger hole, saying, "I was calling the duck a duck. It was quacking like one. It had a bill like one. I was calling a duck a duck" before adding that he had met Sash's girlfriend the previous night. That wasn't the answer Jeff was looking for. "What I was referring to was to ask you just about the comment you made about Sash early in the show being gay. Sounds like you stand by it, that's good," said Jeff with a voice that suggested it was anything but good, refusing to let Shannon expand on his remarks.
nBoston Rob was in the audience (so were Russell and Cirie and Coach and Rupert) and announced that wife Amber, whom he met through Survivor, just had their second baby, a girl named Carina Rose.
nAnd finally, Season 22 of Survivor will introduce a new twist. When players are voted out, they'll be exiled to "Redemption Island" where they'll have to survive alone until the next player is voted out. Those players will then duel, with the winner getting put back into the game. Survivor: Redemption Island starts Feb. 16.
I'd love to hear your thoughts on the season that just ended. I was pleased to see Fabio win. Were you?
(The photo of Fabio after winning the $1 million is by Mark Davis for CBS.)
(P.S.: I fixed my typo. I had Fabio getting five votes to Sash's four and of course we all know that Sash got none.)
Recent Comments