Sometimes dance is a vehicle for conveying serious messages about life and sometimes it's just about the joy of movement.
We got both on So You Think You Can Dance Canada on Monday, with the best routines of the night falling into both camps.
First, the show started with an explanation and an apology.
Judge Jean-Marc Genereux explained why Adam Asselin-Rioux, eliminated last week, was invited back to next season's finals despite having already danced in this season's top 22.
Because Adam had injured his hip flexor just before performing on last Monday's show and because he was still in pain on Tuesday's results show, “he couldn't really show us or Canada what he could do,” Jean-Marc said.
He also offered an apology to Rodrigo Basurto for telling him to “pick it up” after last Tuesday's solo.
Turns out Rodrigo hit his head at the start of his number, resulting in a neck injury and a mild concussion, which explains why the performance wasn't up to par. Lots of us missed it when it happened, including the judges, host Leah Miller and me.
“I just couldn't figure it out because I know how Rodrigo can do a solo,” said guest judge Mary Murphy.
Luckily, Rodrigo's fine and was able to dance for Monday's show. 
Here's how the routines went, in order from my most to least favourite. And bear in mind, these are just my personal opinions and how the routines resonated with me and, in some cases, the differences between one ranking and the next are very, very tiny:
Melissa Mitro and Shane Simpson: Shane and Melissa had the unenviable task of making believable a Sabrina Matthews contemporary routine with a heavy message: about a woman comforting her best friend newly diagnosed with HIV. They accomplished that and also danced beautifully into the bargain, both displaying lovely lines, doing difficult lifts with ease and dancing with an undeniable power and commitment. That's why they're at the top of my list, not because of the standing ovation and the tears from the judges. "You need to know how rare it was, just like a great painting," said Mary, who lost a dance partner to AIDS. "It's an honour to sit here and watch you dance so magnificently ... it was so believable and raw. That's why it brought me to tears.... You're automatically in the top 10, without question.” Guest judge Rex Harrington concurred, saying it brought to mind the anguish of watching a lover die of AIDS then having to get tested himself. Tre Armstrong called it “the most stunning piece of the night for me so far.”
Lindsay Leuschner and Christian Millette: Mary went out on a limb here and declared Lindsay and Christian her favourite dancers in the competition. It's easy to see why after watching this Blake McGrath-choreographed contemporary routine. Christian, a ballroom dancer, was able to take the confusion he confessed in rehearsal and turn it into a strong and nuanced performance onstage. The theme was the power of touch, and Christian and Lindsay were able to touch everyone in the studio with their intense performance. Mary called it “believable and breathable.... It was gorgeous,” and gave the couple first class tickets on her Hot Tamale Train. "Can I just say there's a new chemistry professor in the house here and I believe his name is Christian," she said. Rex praised Lindsay for her "understanding of movement and breath." "She is music, she is freedom and the both of you are fantastic," said Jean-Marc. "I'm so proud of this trio, Blake, Christian and Lindsay."
Jordan Clark and Joey Arrigo: The self-described serious contemporary dancers had a challenge of a different sort, to present a comic Sean Cheesman jazz number about a girl and boy on a first date at the movies. If the routine had just been about the comedy, it might have been good but not great; however, it also delivered challenging lifts and flips and synchronized steps, which Jordan and Joey executed flawlessly and seemingly effortlessly. It had the judges on their feet, Sean jumping for joy and the crowd cheering like crazy. "Only the two of you could have pulled that (side-by-side) section off with the movment, with the feeling, with the technique," Mary said. "You two are definitely the power couple to beat." Jean-Marc went even further: "I might be looking at the champion of Season 4 right there on that stage," he said.
Carlena Britch and Boneless Gulston: This couple is sure on a roll, literally as it turned out on Monday night with a JaeBlaze dancehall routine. I'm so pleased to see this style of dance return to the SYTYCDC stage. It's one of the things that sets this show apart from its U.S. cousin and it's a style I love to watch (hell, I wish I could do it). Carlena and Boneless gave another fantastic performance, following up on their hip-hip triumph of last week, even though Carlena had trouble with the style in rehearsal. And Boneless was just on fire. "Boneless, you just, bam, knocked that one down, didn't you? Carlena, you were fearless like (JaeBlaze) wanted you to be," said Mary. “Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to the new king and queen of swag,” declared Rex. “This is what we call a riddim in Jamaica,” said Tre, who leaped to her feet after the routine along with Jean-Marc. “But we don't want to get rid of none of them, do we?” No, probably not.
Adam LoPapa and Yuliya Zavadska: Let's do a little travelling, shall we, and head from Jamaica to Brazil. That was the origin of this samba choreographed by Gustavo Vargas. Though both Adam and Yuliya were having some trouble with their “booty” in rehearsal, they'd worked it all out by the time they hit the stage. The number was crazy fast, crazy energetic and crazy hot. It mixed capoeira in with the sexy street samba, and Adam and Yuliya were both strong and connected. "You guys are gonna have to change your website to hotdancers.com," Mary told them. "We've heard this phrase before, shake your money-maker. I think they made a lot of money tonight. I think they might be billionaires, Jean-Marc,” she said. "It was sort of like beauty and the beast," said Rex. "Adam, you were this beast around her."
Rodrigo Basurto and Lauren Lyn: This Luther Brown hip-hop routine was about who had the most swag and salsa dancer Lauren gave hip-hop dancer Rodrigo a run for his money, which is hard to do because Rodrigo is, to use Rex's word, “swagalicious.” “You can take off your shirt at every show, it's fine,” he told Rodrigo as the audience roared approval. "That's how the votes work, don't you know?" Mary praised Lauren for keeping up with Rodrigo and Tre praised her for her great stage presence. Jean-Marc said Rodrigo's concussion made him "a little crazier."
(By the way, I inadvertently slighted Luther last week. I loved the routine he choreographed that opened last Tuesday's show, a terrific hip-hop number that blended in ballroom, but I forgot to mention it in my results show recap, so I'm sayin' now.)
Francois Pruneau and Geisha Chin: Last week, these two ended up in bottom three and their partners were eliminated. I'm hoping they do better in the votes this week because, for a ballroom and a contemporary dancer, they did a great job with a very fast hip-hop routine from new choreographer Tucker Barkley. "I am just crazy over the two of you right now," Mary said. Francois was dubbed BBB, “buck ballroom boy,” by Mary and “Franswag” by Tre. And Jean-Marc put them on his VID list, very insane dancers. "You both turned the heat on," he said. Rex said he actually thought hip-hop was their original genre until he consulted his cheat sheet.
JP Dube and Denitsa Ikonomova: This ranking stuff is not an exact science. JP and Denitsa did a perfectly respectable job with this jive choreographed by Danny Arbour (and a shout-out to Danny, a Season 1 competitor returning to the show as a choreographer), but I didn't love it as much as some of the other routines. JP needed a little more emphasis and sharpness, and to dance right through the transitions. The judges generally liked the number, although Tre said JP's kicks could have been sharper and Jean-Marc said he needed to be lighter and faster in his transitions. But Rex said Denitsa reminded him of Cyd Charisse. As for JP, “you're cute as a basket of kittens, but sometimes you've got to tone that down a little bit,” Rex said.
Kevin Howe and Teya Wild: Kevin was one of my favourite dancers coming out of finals week, so it's disappointing to see him falter on a performance night. He had a good week last week with a contemporary routine but was out of his element with this Viennese waltz, choreographed by Pierre Allaire, as was hip-hop dancer Teya. It wasn't awful, but it didn't have the romantic abandon that you'd want from this technically demanding dance. I still love Kevin's lines, though, and Teya looked very pretty. Ballroom expert Mary said she could see Kevin and Teya working too much and the lifts were laboured. Tre agreed and said the emotion of the piece wasn't believable. She drew boos when she said Kevin was turning out not to be a memorable competitor ("I'll prove myself," was Kevin's response). “You guys did it, but it just wasn't enough,” said Tre.
Shelaina Anderson and Matt Marr: I hate to do it, but somebody's got to be at the bottom of the list and this week it's Shelaina and Matt, who are both very good dancers. That being said, this hustle routine choreographed by Maria Torres lacked spark. They were doing the steps but not living them. Matt looked great in his intro and pirouette, but some of the steps were a little “stand and deliver.” And while he and Shelaina pulled off the difficult lifts, the movements didn't flow enough, one to the other. “Disco was about being free and fun and moving," said Rex. "Both of you need to work the hips more. Let it go; it's disco; it's fun, you know, shake it." Jean-Marc agreed with the critiques but said Shelaina and Matt are “so sweet and I'm sure Canada loves you, too.”
We'll soon see whom Canada loves. The results show airs Tuesday at 8 p.m. on CTV, with an opening Bollywood number created by Longinus Fernandes, choreographer for Slumdog Millionaire. Hope you watch and catch the recap here.
And don't forget, you can follow me on Twitter here.
(The photo of Melissa and Shane is courtesy of CTV.)
Recent Comments