Toronto Edition

« Thursday Mail Bag | Main | Clogging Up The Agenda »

May 30, 2008

Comments

mark

Nice to see that the Leafs aren't the only disfunctional team in the league. Melrose? A step up from Tortorella? Please.

Bruce

Talking about dysfunctional, this morning I heard a well know ex Leaf executive's theory about what is going to happen. It goes like this:
Brian Burke is going to preside over the draught for the Ducks, and Fletcher will do the same for the Leafs, then since Burke's refusal to sign an extension the Ducks will fire him and he'll be in the Leaf's GM office before July 1st. Just in time to re-sign Sundin.
I've heard some of his theories in the past, and some have turned out to be bunk, but many have become reality in some form or fashion......
I tend to think this is quite a possbility, considering how dysfunctional a lot of teams are these days......i.e. Barry Melrose and the Bolts.

Clark Aitken

I'd like to see Toronto make a play for Tortorella. He's exactly the type of coach the Leafs need.

The last two coaches in T.O. (Quinn & Maurice) weren't really authoritative in their coaching styles. But Quinn's teams had cagey vets, guys like Thomas, Roberts, Nieuwendyk and Corson, guys who wouldn't let you take a night off. Quinn's teams always showed up to play, because of the veteran leadership in place.

Things started to turn when those guys left, the new room "leaders" (Tucker, McCabe, etc.) didn't have the same pull on the room as those before, or the same desire, and Maurice wasn't the type of coach to scream for three hours a night. All of a sudden, talent took a backseat to passive, lazy play, and the Leafs sunk like a stone.

A coach like Tortorella will get the most out of these guys, because he won't let them take nights off like they had the propensity to do last season. He'd absolutely park somebody like McCabe, Blake or Tucker if they weren't playing to their level, and with all the guys on the Marlies on the fringe of the Leafs roster, he'd basically be putting that 12th forward and 6th defenseman spot up for auction each night to the guy who's going to work the hardest.

It would be an immediate 180 in terms of team mentality, and with Toskala backing everything up, it would be a HUGE improvement over last season's club.

frost

Melrose also won a calder cup with with Adirondack Red Wings in 91-92

roger

Great move by the Bolts - Melrose has long deserved another shot. I also agree with Clark Aitken - the Leafs should give Tortorella consideration for the coaching job.

David

I can't believe Tortorella will be gone! His departure is Tampa's loss in my opinion. Tortorella's energy and passion led the team to many successful seasons which culminated in the 2004 Stanley Cup. Too bad the 2005 season did not happen (shame on the NHL/owners/player reps for that one). It's unfortunate that Tampa was victim of the "perfect storm"(several key injuries to a team with little depth, ownership distractions, and a couple trade decisions that did not work out)this year. It's amazing how one trade gone bad can kill a team with little depth (Modin for Denis). Not to mention that Tampa should have picked up Bryzgalov off waivers back in November! And I guess a "perfect storm" type season results in the garage sale at the end... Richards in a Lightning jersey will be sorely missed. Tortorella - thank you for your hard work in Tampa. Go Lightning!

Craig

Back in February, I asked the guys on NHL radio what they thought about the chances of Tortorella becoming the coach of Leafs? They pretty much just dis-missed my question.

I too think it would be a great fit for T.O., and now the timing maybe coming together... Just like I thought it might months ago!!

Sorry to be on the soapbox, I just didn't get much respect from the NHL radio guys. Have a good day!

Chris

I recently read that Mats Sundin was awarded the Mark Messier Award for Leadership for this past year. By refusing to waive his no trade clause, Sundin certainly did display “leadership” by acting in his own self-interest and stiffing a hockey club and city that has embraced him for years. His leadership appears to have inspired others to similarly refuse to waive their no trade clause. I will be thinking of Sundin’s great leadership last year when I watch all the young prospects flourish the Leafs could have had if Sundin had agreed to be traded, or as I watch the Leafs fail to make the playoffs again for the next year or so because those same prospects are not on the team.

I often hear of Sundin’s “leadership” of the Leafs, refusal to waive his no trade clause aside, but I cannot see it. Certainly, he gets points, is a gentleman, and I presume he is supportive of other players. Not that dissimilar from Pavel Bure who was no leader. But does Sundin push and apply pressure to other players to step up their game, or is he just too nice? With all the other players refusing to waive their no trade clause, despite the Leafs not being a playoff bound team, it seems that life is pretty cushy with the Leafs. Is Sundin the glue that binds the team together, or a key catalyst for team chemistry? I think not. Has he made any other player much better? I don’t think so.

If Sundin is back in a Leaf uniform next year, I will be booing him. Of course, I will be booing him as he skates on my tv, who can afford to go to a game anyway?

EJ

roger said: "Not to mention that Tampa should have picked up Bryzgalov off waivers back in November!"

Sorry, Roger, but Bryzgalov was claimed by the team with the worst record in the league at the time.

Darnell

I'm not surprised that Barry Melrose may move on. Since ESPN walked from the NHL, he's spotlighted as the hockey guy, but that can't be fulfilling. My guess is that he stayed with ESPN hoping they would snatch the broadcast agreement from NBC or Versus, but that didn't happen. Good luck Barry if you take the job!

Ken

Concerning the comments on John Tortorella, anything would be better than the hiring of Ron Wilson!
I do agree that the Leaf lineup needs a task master who will shake up the indifferent play of some of the veterans. As for Mats Sundin, sign him for $8 million but do not give a no-trade contract. That way he continues as a Leaf and gives the Leafs the option of a February trade for young talent. Get a list of 8 teams that he would be open for a trade so he has some semblance of control. Otherwise, cut him loose, sign some younger free agents and develop the draft talents over the next couple of years. Give me that general manager's job and I'll soon fashion a champion!!!

Bruce

Regarding Sudin's no trade clause. Those who come down on him for not waiving it make me laugh. Have you never heard of job security?
If your boss came to you and said "Hey Chris you're doing a great job but, the company's not doing too well, so I need to send you off to some other place to allow me to bring in some younger and less paid people"

As if you'd go...........

Ryan

I love how only in Toronto an article about Barry Melrose and Pittsburgh makes people start to talk about the Leafs!?!?

I'm a Leaf fan myself, but come on, if they aren't playing...don't talk about them!!!!

I'm surprised no one in the comment section has mentioned Barry's role in the '93 "Greatest Hockey Sin Ever"!!!!!

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

The Spin on Sports by Damien Cox



  • Damien Cox, the Star's hockey columnist and associate sports editor, takes turns stirring up trouble and chuckling at the foibles of the sporting world. He'll start with hockey, Canada's ongoing passion play, and stick his nose into a few other games and places where athletes reside. You'll love some of his thoughts, hate others and get a chance to give your two cents on all of them.

    Click here to send Damien your Maple Leafs or hockey question and he'll answer a selection in the blog.

del.icio.us

Advertisement


Legal Notice

  • TheStar.com
    Copyright Toronto Star Newspapers Limited. All rights reserved. The views expressed are those of the writer and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Toronto Star or www.thestar.com. The Star is not responsible for the content or views expressed on external sites. Distribution, transmission or republication of any material is strictly prohibited without the prior written permission of Toronto Star Newspapers Limited.
    For information please contact us using our webmaster form. www.thestar.com online since 1996.